Tolkien seemed inconsistent and the movies used light to match the book’s conflicted tones. Was Gollum dark-skinned or light-skinned? J.R.R.
The “let’s blog about it” point of view has prevailed in my mind. But this is one of those potentially incendiary questions and I have debated whether to address it on the blog. You said nothing wrong or which offends me.
ANSWER: How does one respond to this question? Submitted in June 2018, I have cringed every time I’ve looked at the message.